P2PU & a course on Open Governance

I am very interested in alternative models of education – I recently read the book DIY U which provides quite a comprehensive overview of the problems of third level education in the US and makes a convincing case for alternative models of education.

One such (still experimental) model is P2PU – peer-to-peer university. I’m not entirely sure how it works, so I signed up to a course to find out. At some high-level, the P2PU model seems to put much more emphasis on students learning from each other than the more traditional teacher/student relationship. However, I don’t really know how well this can work in practice.

The range of courses on offer was somewhat limited, but I did manage to find a course which seems quite fascinating – it’s a course entitled Open Governance. The course is about alternative ways of supporting decision-making within groups of people; new ways which are made possible by the Internet in particular.

The idea fits nicely with notions of crowd-sourcing, which have been receiving much attention lately. It’s also interesting from the point of view of Jolitics, a site to which I signed up to, but did not really engage strongly with – I’ll probably need to dig into that a bit more for this course.

Of course, there are lots of issues and problems with Open Goverance in general, eg:

  • there is already an established way of doing things – new models like this would probably require very fundamental changes, changes to the way countries are constituted in many cases – obviously, this would not sit well with the establishment;
  • almost all systems can be gamed and naive open systems are definitely open to gaming by interested parties – how to prevent this and how much it needs to be prevented probably needs to be considered;
  • here in Ireland, when we vote on referenda relating to fundamental ways in which our society works, it seems to me that people often cast a vote based on much misinformation and often ignorance – it seems that more devolved structures which give more and more people a voice on more and more issues could suffer more from this (although perhaps this issue only really arises because the issues that go to referendum are fundamental and hence typically are complex with many ramifications).

What’s the point of this post, other than to tell the world what I’m up to? Part of the modus operandi of the course is to put content on blogs. Hence, I’ll be putting content up here which relates to Open Governance; it may seem out of place with the rest of the content here, so this post is my attempt to explain why I’m making these postings.

Advertisements

About morphousmusings

Engineer, thinker, tinker, drinker, talker, walker, hiker, biker, liker, lover View all posts by morphousmusings

2 responses to “P2PU & a course on Open Governance

  • John Maguire

    Sean

    Just curious about your views on Open Governance and P2P learning based upon your own experiences over the years. In the business world I’ve tended to find that it can work quite well for small teams / companies, but that when you hit a certain event horizon it actually stalls progress.
    Obviously I can’t comment on how it works in academe but would be curious.

    J

    • morphousmusings

      Hi John,

      Sorry for getting back to you so late. I’m afraid I can’t give any deep insight on this as I don’t have lots of experience dealing with these issues first hand. However, the course I’m doing does have some old hands who have lots of experience working within such communities, so I’ll extract their knowledge and try to share it with you.

      I’ll let you know once I’ve been able to digest it myself.

      BR,
      Seán.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: